Saturday Night Live Season 42, Episode 20: Melissa McCarthy joins the Five-Timers Club!

How’s the Cold Open?

I’ve definitely been critical of Baldwin’s performance as Trump in recent weeks as largely being a “Fill-In-The-Blanks” impression, and it isn’t as though this week’s showing was necessarily any better about that.

I feel like this week was just to some degree the most absurd and stupid week in the history of the Trump Presidency, where the sheer vain idiocy came so far to the forefront of President Wario’s actions that any repetition would be deeply amusing in a sort of “Laughing at the Mushroom Cloud” sort of way.

So, yeah, Baldwin is doing his standard shtick, but I couldn’t stop stress-laughing remembering how barely exaggerated the actions were this week. The actual comedy star of this one was Michael Che as Lester Holt, whose delivery of the line “Nothing matters” taps into that weird pervading nihilism about the whole thing.

Also, any time we can mock Paul Ryan, let’s do it. Bring ice cream you Randian motherfucker.

I’m mad about politics this week. The sketch was funny.

Who’s Hosting?

It always kind of surprises me that Melissa McCarthy didn’t come up through SNL. She seems like the sort who would have been a smashing success here, a brilliantly broad comedic performer with a penchant for really digging underneath the characters. She’s always been SNL-adjacent anyway, kicking off the superstar portion of her career in a movie starring Kristen Wiig, so what would it have hurt to have had it every week?

She enters the Five-Timers Club this week, the second this year (there will ultimately be three), and she is absolutely deserving. No non-cast member has felt quite so at home as McCarthy, she’s up there with luminaries like Steve Martin, Alec Baldwin, or Justin Timberlake.

What Sketches Are Worth Watching?

“First Birthday”

A weird recurring sketch that tries to explain those suburban mom trends, I’m a fan of weirdly sinister comedy and this absolutely has it in spades. A bizarre, Stepford-esque escalation of finding “your animal” and your nature, the great little weird behavior details and the increasingly dark/glassy-eyed performance from everyone all builds to a nice comedy crescendo.

“Production Logo”

A perfect 10-to-1 sketch, the kind of sketch that you’re not sure what exactly the thought process was that led to it, but you’re happy someone thought of it. Absurd, but played with a totally straight face. Don’t know what made me laugh so much about Melissa McCarthy’s depressed logo woman, but made me laugh it did,

“Kyle and Leslie”

This romance between Kyle Mooney and Leslie Jones has been one of the more surprising delights of this season, a romance surprisingly sweet and funny as it is weirdly told and well put-together. It actually pulls from a real place if this romance existed (their varying levels of success) and then pushes it in a legitimately interesting way until it takes the comedy turn, which actually may be the hardest I’ve laughed this season so far.

No shit. I was scream-laughing.

“Sean Spicer Returns”

Spicey, Sean Spicer if you’re nasty, may legitimately be McCarthy’s greatest character, a bundle of anger and rage and genuine nervous fear that explodes in comedic service of a total buffoon. McCarthy plays Spicer with everything she’s got, and I think it’s one of the few that finds no diminishing returns. Yeah, Spicey has thrown shit before, but that column throw is a legitimately hilarious escalation, it always feels like you’re finding something new. Even if you’re just reciting what happens (Spicer really did hide “among” the bushes), McCarthy finds the comedic gold therein and pulls it out, not just reciting.

Plus, I will never not laugh at the use of the podium.

“Film Panel”

Considering real-life Classical Hollywood was only slightly more dehumanizing than these folks describe, I’m impressed how much they manage to pull out and the delight with which McKinnon and McCarthy’s old actress describe all manner of twisted things. Just a great duo performance, and the showcase for McKinnon’s talents that works every time.

“Melissa McCarthy Mother’s Day Monologue”

Just a fun little piece to kick off the show, I always love the various shenanigans they pretend are going on behind the scenes at SNL and I’m also a fan that they keep McCarthy’s Llama recurring.

What Didn’t Work?

“Amazon Echo”

Reasonably committed, but honestly, there’s not really any gags that haven’t 100% been done before, this is just kind of your standard group of old people gags given “relevance” by tying it to a new piece of technology.

“Game Show”

Carried entirely on McCarthy’s physical humor here, it kind of runs into a rut a little too fast, telegraphing all its gags from the first pie-to-the-face. I’ll admit to laughing at the “washing off” stuff, but everything else is just not all there.

Weekend Update!

In a weird way, this week more than ever, Weekend Update is feeling the strain of keeping up with an exceptionally dumb administration. One has to wonder what it would have been like for this show to operate under Nixon, keeping up with the vitriol and the stupidity and the sheer weird baffling behavior is plenty of material that you’re still never going to feel better comedically than the dark joke of seeing it actually happen.

At this point, there’s just a general need for a little catharsis, a barely concealed need to throw up the hands and just ask “What the fuck?” While these guys aren’t as good as Seth Meyers (As far as mainstream goes. When you’re talking non-mainstream sources, no one is beating Chapo Trap House for the cathartic political comedy), Jost and Che are getting a few good shots in this week, my favorite being Jost hitting Spicer and Trump over Spicey diving in the bushes without warning as that’s usually Trump’s move.

Correspondents were good this week. Cathy Anne actually made me laugh this week with a solid group of hits that were clearly connecting on Trump. The concept of the character as a woman at her last rope is finally coming through here, and it’s funnier than she’s been in her past. Pete Davidson also did a nice little personal bit about being in rehab, and I hope all goes well for him.

Did You Actually Watch The Musical Guest?

Oh yeah. HAIM is the bees knees.

MVPs!

An ensemble show largely, but Cecily KILLED it as a straight-man this week, so major props to being able to do that. And Cathy Anne actually worked this time around.

Beck Bennett – 4
Cecily Strong – 3

Kate McKinnon – 2
Bobby Moynihan – 2
Mikey Day – 2
Vanessa Bayer – 1
Jost and Che – 1
Leslie Jones – 1
Kyle Mooney – 1
Kenan Thompson – 1
Melissa Villaseñor – 1
Ensemble – 1

Final Thoughts!

A great week, one almost certainly buoyed by having Melissa McCarthy’s comedic presence around. While not quite as experimental or sheerly-skilled as some of the better episodes of this season, it’s a solid group of sketches that land more hits than misses.

Season Rankings (Shamelessly stolen from SNL Scorecard)

  1. Dave Chappelle
  2. Tom Hanks
  3. Kristen Stewart
  4. Lin-Manuel Miranda
  5. Louis C.K.
  6. Emma Stone
  7. Aziz Ansari
  8. Chris Pine
  9. Melissa McCarthy
  10. Scarlett Johansson
  11. Alec Baldwin
  12. Kristen Wiig
  13. Margot Robbie
  14. Casey Affleck
  15. Benedict Cumberbatch
  16. John Cena
  17. Felicity Jones
  18. Octavia Spencer
  19. Emily Blunt
  20. Jimmy Fallon

Next Week: THE SEASON ENDS. Dwayne Johnson also joins the Five-Timers Club.

Advertisements